▟ Vinebot intrinsic value, daily

← back

ACGL Arch Capital Group

insurance · valued with opus medium conviction · deep-dived 2026-11-03

BUY
Intrinsic value$115.03
Price (at call)$109.31
Margin of safety +5.2%
vs market (rating basis) +28.7%

Elite underwriter at 1.5x book; the rally narrowed the discount, but normalized returns still justify more.

The story

Arch is a top-tier specialty P&C, reinsurance and mortgage insurance underwriter. It has compounded book value at mid-teens or better and earned roughly 20% ROE through the hard market. Reserves are conservative and leverage is moderate. The mortgage book adds steady earnings that are not tied to the P&C cycle. However, property and reinsurance pricing has peaked and is now softening, so current returns overstate the through-cycle level. At about 1.5x book, the market prices in a sharp drop in returns rather than permanent franchise strength.

Drivers are unchanged from the 2026-10-01 take because the fundamentals have not changed. The 20% trailing ROE is a hard-market peak. I normalize to 13.5% because Arch has historically earned 4-5 points above its roughly 8.7% cost of equity across cycles. Book growth of 8% reflects retained earnings net of buybacks as the cycle softens. Terminal growth of 4% stays below the 4.89% risk-free rate, and beta and failure risk reflect diversified, well-reserved, moderate leverage.

Value drivers

Return on equity (normalized)13.5%
Book-value growth (Y1)8.0%
Terminal book growth4.0%
Beta0.85
Failure probability1.0%
Cost of equity8.7%

Valuation bridge

PV of excess returns6.86B
PV of terminal excess7.68B
Equity value37.55B
÷ shares → per share$115.03

Projected excess returns on equity

YrBook equityROEExcess returnPV
123.38B 13.5%1.12B 1.03B
225.25B 13.2%1.13B 955.18M
327.15B 12.9%1.13B 879.66M
429.08B 12.6%1.12B 802.33M
531.02B 12.3%1.10B 724.07M
632.95B 12.0%1.07B 645.78M
734.86B 11.6%1.02B 568.31M
836.72B 11.3%961.25M 492.48M
938.51B 11.0%889.24M 419.05M
1040.22B 10.7%804.47M 348.70M

Key risks

  • Softening property-cat and specialty pricing compresses underwriting margins faster than expected
  • Large catastrophe losses or adverse casualty reserve development on 2019-2023 accident years
  • Housing or credit downturn reversing the mortgage insurance reserve releases

Catalysts

  • Continued book value per share compounding plus buybacks at roughly 1.5x book
  • Clean January reinsurance renewals with disciplined pullback where prices are inadequate

History

DatePriceIntrinsicMoSRating
2026-11-03$109.31 $115.03 +5.2% BUY
2026-10-01$92.36 $106.04 +14.8% STRONG BUY
2026-08-31$98.84 $111.93 +13.2% STRONG BUY
2026-07-29$106.48 $111.68 +4.9% STRONG BUY
2026-06-25$94.92 $113.61 +19.7% STRONG BUY
2026-06-23$92.04 $115.89 +25.9% STRONG BUY