▟ Vinebot intrinsic value, daily

← back

AJG Arthur J. Gallagher & Co.

insurance · valued with opus medium conviction · deep-dived 2026-11-06

SELL
Intrinsic value$147.23
Price (at call)$288.11
Margin of safety -48.9%
vs market (rating basis) -39.2%

Elite broker, but at 3.2x a goodwill-swollen book the price assumes roll-up returns never fade.

The story

AJG is a top-tier, asset-light insurance broker with sticky commission and fee revenue, about 18% operating margins, and a long record of roll-ups. Book equity has grown to $23.3B, mostly from the equity raised to fund the AssuredPartners deal, and that book is dominated by goodwill and intangibles. Trailing GAAP ROE of 6.7% is held down by amortization of acquired intangibles and by raised capital that is not yet fully earning. Organic growth is mid-to-high single digits and the property and casualty pricing cycle is softening.

I cut normalized ROE from 14% to 13%. Adjusted earnings of about $2.8-3.0B on the larger $23B goodwill-heavy book work out to roughly 12-13%. That is above the 6.7% GAAP figure because amortization is not an economic cost. It is below the old 14% because the AssuredPartners equity dilutes returns. Book growth slows to 7% as deal-driven equity growth fades, with terminal growth capped at 4.5%. Beta (0.85) and failure risk (1%) are unchanged for a fee-based, low-leverage broker.

Value drivers

Return on equity (normalized)13.0%
Book-value growth (Y1)7.0%
Terminal book growth4.5%
Beta0.85
Failure probability1.0%
Cost of equity8.7%

Valuation bridge

PV of excess returns6.27B
PV of terminal excess8.54B
Equity value37.75B
÷ shares → per share$147.23

Projected excess returns on equity

YrBook equityROEExcess returnPV
123.32B 13.0%1.01B 931.02M
224.95B 12.7%1.02B 861.88M
326.63B 12.5%1.02B 792.57M
428.35B 12.2%1.01B 723.58M
530.10B 12.0%992.81M 655.35M
631.87B 11.7%968.49M 588.34M
733.66B 11.4%935.40M 522.94M
835.45B 11.2%893.20M 459.54M
937.24B 10.9%841.60M 398.48M
1039.02B 10.7%780.44M 340.07M

Key risks

  • Softening P&C pricing reduces commission growth and organic growth
  • AssuredPartners integration and continued acquisitions at high multiples erode returns on the goodwill-heavy book
  • Falling interest rates cut fiduciary investment income, and organic growth decelerates from a high base

Catalysts

  • AssuredPartners synergies arrive and adjusted ROE moves back toward 14-15%
  • Organic growth holds at 7% or more through the softening pricing cycle

History

DatePriceIntrinsicMoSRating
2026-11-06$288.11 $147.23 -48.9% SELL
2026-10-06$227.24 $146.20 -35.7% HOLD
2026-09-03$264.46 $82.02 -69.0% STRONG SELL
2026-08-03$249.42 $93.82 -62.4% HOLD
2026-06-30$227.12 $99.72 -56.1% HOLD
2026-06-23$215.84 $129.22 -40.1% HOLD