ALL Allstate
Peak underwriting profits at 2.2x book; normalization to mid-teens ROE leaves the stock overvalued.
The story
Allstate is a scale US personal-lines franchise. After the 2022-23 auto losses, aggressive rate increases and cost cuts have produced peak-cycle profits: trailing ROE is about 41% and operating margin is 20%. The balance sheet is solid, and the sale of the benefits businesses leaves a leaner, more capital-light P&C mix. Still, auto profitability is mean-reverting as rate adequacy draws competitors back, and catastrophe volatility is structural. At about 2.2x book, the market is pricing in returns well above any through-the-cycle norm.
I nudged normalized ROE from 16% to 16.5% because another year of disciplined underwriting and the lower-capital business mix support slightly higher sustainable returns. I still won't extrapolate a 41% peak that depends on light catastrophe losses and auto pricing at its most favorable point. Book growth stays at 8% in year 1 because heavy buybacks and dividends absorb most of the excess earnings. Terminal growth of 4% stays below the 4.86% risk-free rate. Beta stays at the 0.9 industry anchor.
Value drivers
| Return on equity (normalized) | 16.5% |
| Book-value growth (Y1) | 8.0% |
| Terminal book growth | 4.0% |
| Beta | 0.90 |
| Failure probability | 1.0% |
| Cost of equity | 8.9% |
Valuation bridge
| PV of excess returns | 11.88B |
| PV of terminal excess | 8.88B |
| Equity value | 48.88B |
| ÷ shares → per share | $197.52 |
Projected excess returns on equity
| Yr | Book equity | ROE | Excess return | PV |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 28.61B | 16.5% | 2.17B | 1.99B |
| 2 | 30.90B | 15.9% | 2.15B | 1.82B |
| 3 | 33.23B | 15.3% | 2.11B | 1.63B |
| 4 | 35.60B | 14.6% | 2.04B | 1.45B |
| 5 | 37.97B | 14.0% | 1.94B | 1.27B |
| 6 | 40.33B | 13.4% | 1.81B | 1.08B |
| 7 | 42.66B | 12.8% | 1.65B | 906.95M |
| 8 | 44.94B | 12.2% | 1.46B | 736.14M |
| 9 | 47.13B | 11.5% | 1.24B | 573.14M |
| 10 | 49.23B | 10.9% | 984.56M | 419.38M |
Key risks
- Auto margin compression as competitors cut rates and loss-cost inflation (repair, medical, social inflation) resumes
- Severe catastrophe year (hurricane, convective storms, wildfire) erasing a large share of annual earnings and book
- Regulatory pushback on homeowners and auto rate filings in key states limiting pricing power
Catalysts
- Continued policy-in-force growth showing that market share can rise without sacrificing combined ratio
- Large buyback execution and reserve releases supporting EPS while ROE stays elevated