▟ Vinebot intrinsic value, daily

← back

ATO Atmos Energy

energy · valued with opus medium conviction · deep-dived 2026-11-10

SELL
Intrinsic value$77.35
Price (at call)$173.35
Margin of safety -55.4%
vs market (rating basis) -35.3%

A top-quality gas monopoly, but the market pays well above invested capital for returns near the cost of capital.

The story

Atmos is the largest pure-play US gas distributor, a regulated monopoly concentrated in Texas whose formula-rate mechanisms (GRIP, annual rate filings) let it recover a ~$4B/yr capex program with unusually little regulatory lag. It is a mature utility in a heavy-investment phase. Rate base is compounding at low double digits and revenue at mid-single digits, while returns sit only modestly above a low cost of capital. Value creation is real but thin per dollar invested, and the market prices that safety and visibility at a large premium to invested capital.

I raised margin from 37% to 38.5% because TTM margins reached 38.5% on faster rate recovery, and a regulated cost-plus structure makes that level sustainable. Sales-to-capital moves up modestly from 0.30 to 0.33 because pass-through gas costs distort recent ratios and formula rates now earn a return on new capital sooner. Beta drops to 0.55, in line with how regulated gas distributors have actually traded. Even with these changes, an investment-heavy DCF will likely still land well below the price; the gap is the premium the market pays for allowed returns above the cost of equity, not a driver error.

Value drivers

Revenue growth (Y1)6.5%
Terminal growth3.0%
Forecast horizon10y
Target operating margin38.5%
Years to target margin2
Sales-to-capital0.33
Beta0.55
Failure probability1.0%
Cost of capital (WACC)7.2%
Terminal WACC8.8%

Valuation bridge

PV of explicit FCFF7.74B
PV of terminal value14.26B
Equity value13.07B
÷ shares → per share$77.35

Projected free cash flow to the firm

YrRevenueGrowthMarginNOPATReinvestFCFFPV
1 5.24B 6.5% 38.5% 1.64B 969.39M 667.81M 622.78M
2 5.56B 6.1% 38.5% 1.74B 970.63M 766.03M 666.22M
3 5.88B 5.7% 38.5% 1.84B 964.41M 871.63M 706.96M
4 6.19B 5.3% 38.5% 1.93B 950.30M 983.66M 744.03M
5 6.50B 4.9% 38.5% 2.03B 928.00M 1.10B 777.05M
6 6.80B 4.6% 38.5% 2.12B 897.28M 1.22B 805.69M
7 7.08B 4.2% 38.5% 2.21B 858.07M 1.35B 829.67M
8 7.35B 3.8% 38.5% 2.29B 810.40M 1.48B 848.78M
9 7.60B 3.4% 38.5% 2.37B 754.44M 1.62B 862.89M
10 7.82B 3.0% 38.5% 2.44B 690.50M 1.75B 871.93M

Key risks

  • Texas regulatory or political pushback on formula-rate recovery or allowed ROE
  • Electrification and gas-ban policies shortening the useful life of the pipe being installed today (stranded asset risk)
  • Rising interest rates lifting the cost of capital and pressuring the utility valuation premium
  • Safety incidents (e.g., the 2018 Dallas explosion) triggering penalties and disallowed costs

Catalysts

  • Constructive Texas rate case and GRIP outcomes sustaining 6-8% EPS growth
  • Falling long-term rates re-rating bond-proxy utilities
  • Data-center and population-driven load growth in Texas expanding the customer base

History

DatePriceIntrinsicMoSRating
2026-11-10$173.35 $77.35 -55.4% SELL
2026-10-07$159.74 $59.16 -63.0% SELL
2026-09-03$167.68 $36.42 -78.3% STRONG SELL
2026-07-31$174.26 $65.23 -62.6% SELL
2026-06-26$173.67 $67.27 -61.3% SELL
2026-06-23$171.08 $63.58 -62.8% SELL