▟ Vinebot intrinsic value, daily

← back

BEN Franklin Resources

capital_markets · valued with opus medium conviction · deep-dived 2026-11-03

BUY
Intrinsic value$24.07
Price (at call)$31.97
Margin of safety -24.7%
vs market (rating basis) +17.1%

Margins keep sliding; Franklin earns roughly its cost of equity, so it's worth near book, below price.

The story

Franklin is a broad, diversified asset manager (about $1.6T AUM) whose fee base faces steady pressure from passive products and fee compression, plus continuing Western Asset outflows. GAAP returns are depressed by Legg Mason and Putnam acquisition amortization and restructuring; adjusted earnings of about $1.1B imply roughly 9% on book. The balance sheet is sound, with modest leverage and large seed and investment holdings. Operating margin fell again, from 10.9% to 10.1%, so the recovery I hoped for has not shown up yet.

I cut normalized ROE from 11% to 10% because margins kept compressing and adjusted ROE is stuck near 9%. A partial rebound in alternatives and private markets justifies setting it slightly above trailing, but not at the old level. With cost of equity around 9.8%, the franchise earns about its hurdle, so it is worth close to book of roughly $23.80 per share. I kept book growth at 3% because a high dividend payout limits how much the company retains.

Value drivers

Return on equity (normalized)10.0%
Book-value growth (Y1)3.0%
Terminal book growth3.0%
Beta1.10
Failure probability1.0%
Cost of equity9.8%

Valuation bridge

PV of excess returns130.62M
PV of terminal excess144.68M
Equity value12.23B
÷ shares → per share$24.07

Projected excess returns on equity

YrBook equityROEExcess returnPV
112.08B 10.0%18.84M 17.15M
212.44B 10.0%19.41M 16.08M
312.81B 10.0%19.99M 15.08M
413.20B 10.0%20.59M 14.14M
513.59B 10.0%21.21M 13.26M
614.00B 10.0%21.84M 12.43M
714.42B 10.0%22.50M 11.66M
814.85B 10.0%23.17M 10.93M
915.30B 10.0%23.87M 10.25M
1015.76B 10.0%24.58M 9.61M

Key risks

  • Western Asset outflows and legal/regulatory overhang deepen
  • Ongoing fee compression from passive and ETF substitution in active equity and fixed income
  • Market drawdown hits AUM-linked revenue against a sticky cost base and acquisition amortization

Catalysts

  • Cost-savings program lifting adjusted operating margin back toward mid-20s
  • Alternatives/private credit (Benefit Street, Clarion, Lexington) fundraising driving mix and fee-rate improvement

History

DatePriceIntrinsicMoSRating
2026-11-03$31.97 $24.07 -24.7% BUY
2026-10-08$32.48 $26.05 -19.8% BUY
2026-09-14$33.65 $29.10 -13.5% STRONG BUY
2026-08-19$33.99 $8.89 -73.8% SELL
2026-07-24$32.29 $15.20 -52.9% HOLD
2026-06-29$33.21 $19.98 -39.8% BUY
2026-06-23$33.79 $20.64 -38.9% BUY