▟ Vinebot intrinsic value, daily

← back

CFG Citizens Financial Group

bank · valued with opus medium conviction · deep-dived 2026-11-20

STRONG BUY
Intrinsic value$59.30
Price (at call)$60.51
Margin of safety -2.0%
vs market (rating basis) +41.6%

The repair is real, but a 10.5% ROE barely covers the cost of equity, so about 1.05x book is fair, not cheap.

The story

Citizens is a mid-sized regional bank about halfway through its repair: the legacy low-yield swaps and securities are rolling off, the private bank build-out is adding fee and deposit growth, and revenue has climbed to 8.93B from 8.25B. Trailing ROE is 9.4%, still below the cost of equity, though it is improving as net interest margin recovers. The balance sheet is sound (CET1 around 10.5%, and commercial real estate exposure is shrinking), but book equity includes preferreds and unrealized securities losses, so common returns are lower than the headline. The stock has fallen to about 1.05x book, from 1.12x at my last take, so less of the improvement is already priced in.

I kept the drivers from my last take because nothing material changed. Trailing ROE of 9.4% is moving toward a through-the-cycle 10.5% as swaps run off and the private bank scales, but a mid-sized regional bank with commercial real estate and deposit-cost exposure should not be modeled above that. A cost of equity of about 10.2% leaves almost no excess return, so the value should land near book (about 58 per share) plus a small premium. Book growth of 4% reflects retained earnings net of buybacks; the 2.5% terminal rate is well below the 5.05% risk-free rate.

Value drivers

Return on equity (normalized)10.5%
Book-value growth (Y1)4.0%
Terminal book growth2.5%
Beta1.15
Failure probability1.0%
Cost of equity10.2%

Valuation bridge

PV of excess returns460.45M
PV of terminal excess444.68M
Equity value24.86B
÷ shares → per share$59.30

Projected excess returns on equity

YrBook equityROEExcess returnPV
124.21B 10.5%66.08M 59.95M
225.17B 10.5%68.73M 56.56M
326.14B 10.5%71.36M 53.28M
427.10B 10.5%73.98M 50.11M
528.05B 10.5%76.57M 47.05M
628.98B 10.5%79.12M 44.11M
729.90B 10.5%81.62M 41.29M
830.80B 10.5%84.07M 38.58M
931.67B 10.5%86.45M 35.99M
1032.51B 10.5%88.76M 33.52M

Key risks

  • Credit cycle turn in commercial real estate, especially office, or in leveraged commercial and industrial loans pushes provisions above normalized levels
  • Deposit competition or rate cuts compress net interest margin before the swap and securities repricing benefit fully arrives
  • Private bank hires fail to produce profitable growth, leaving the expense base elevated

Catalysts

  • Net interest margin expansion as legacy swaps and low-yield securities roll off through 2026-2027
  • Steady progress toward medium-term ROTCE targets of 16-18%, plus capital returned through buybacks

History

DatePriceIntrinsicMoSRating
2026-11-20$60.51 $59.30 -2.0% STRONG BUY
2026-11-03$64.93 $60.61 -6.6% STRONG BUY
2026-10-15$62.57 $54.16 -13.4% STRONG BUY
2026-09-28$65.53 $50.44 -23.0% STRONG BUY
2026-09-09$69.99 $53.10 -24.1% STRONG BUY
2026-08-21$69.71 $53.92 -22.6% STRONG BUY
2026-08-04$72.70 $49.39 -32.1% STRONG BUY
2026-07-15$70.32 $54.33 -22.7% STRONG BUY
2026-06-26$70.66 $55.41 -21.6% STRONG BUY
2026-06-23$68.99 $55.06 -20.2% STRONG BUY