▟ Vinebot intrinsic value, daily

← back

CINF Cincinnati Financial

insurance · valued with opus medium conviction · deep-dived 2026-11-13

HOLD
Intrinsic value$169.15
Price (at call)$190.31
Margin of safety -11.1%
vs market (rating basis) +6.3%

Quality insurer, but 1.84x book prices peak returns; a 13% normal ROE says fully valued.

The story

Cincinnati Financial is a disciplined, agency-driven P&C insurer that also runs a large equity-heavy investment portfolio, so its reported earnings swing with stock-market marks and catastrophe losses. Trailing ROE of 15.9% reflects a strong underwriting year plus equity gains. Through-cycle combined ratios in the mid-90s and steady investment income support something closer to 13%. The balance sheet is conservatively reserved and lightly levered, but the 15% move in the stock since my last take means the shares now sit at roughly 1.84x book ($103 a share), which already prices in near-peak returns.

Nothing fundamental has changed. The 15.9% trailing ROE is lifted by equity marks and a benign catastrophe year, so I keep normalized ROE at 13% instead of extrapolating the peak. Book growth, terminal growth (below the 5.1% risk-free rate), low beta and minimal failure risk are also unchanged, since the franchise and its risk profile are the same.

Value drivers

Return on equity (normalized)13.0%
Book-value growth (Y1)6.5%
Terminal book growth4.0%
Beta0.70
Failure probability0.6%
Cost of equity8.3%

Valuation bridge

PV of excess returns4.57B
PV of terminal excess5.65B
Equity value25.97B
÷ shares → per share$169.15

Projected excess returns on equity

YrBook equityROEExcess returnPV
115.91B 13.0%755.30M 697.71M
216.95B 12.7%752.67M 642.28M
318.00B 12.4%744.56M 586.92M
419.07B 12.1%730.62M 532.02M
520.15B 11.8%710.52M 477.94M
621.24B 11.5%683.99M 425.02M
722.32B 11.2%650.82M 373.58M
823.40B 10.9%610.85M 323.90M
924.47B 10.6%564.00M 276.26M
1025.51B 10.3%510.26M 230.88M

Key risks

  • A severe catastrophe season (wildfire or convective storms) pushes the combined ratio above 100%
  • An equity market drawdown hits book value through the large common-stock portfolio
  • Social-inflation reserve strengthening in commercial casualty lines

Catalysts

  • Continued commercial and personal lines rate adequacy keeps the combined ratio in the low 90s
  • Higher reinvestment yields on the bond portfolio lift recurring investment income

History

DatePriceIntrinsicMoSRating
2026-11-13$190.31 $169.15 -11.1% HOLD
2026-10-13$165.55 $166.82 +0.8% BUY
2026-09-10$169.21 $174.14 +2.9% STRONG BUY
2026-08-10$176.86 $172.99 -2.2% BUY
2026-07-07$189.59 $175.39 -7.5% HOLD
2026-06-23$175.81 $175.62 -0.1% BUY