▟ Vinebot intrinsic value, daily

← back

CMS CMS Energy

utility · valued with opus medium conviction · deep-dived 2026-11-06

HOLD
Intrinsic value$56.32
Price (at call)$70.68
Margin of safety -20.3%
vs market (rating basis) -16.0%

Quality Michigan compounder, but $71 prices in returns regulators won't allow; the rally widened the gap.

The story

CMS Energy is a pure-play Michigan regulated utility (Consumers Energy) with a constructive commission, fully forward test years, and a large capex plan driving about 7-8% annual rate-base growth. Trailing ROE of 9.8% is close to Michigan's allowed return of about 9.9%; parent-level leverage and good execution have historically lifted consolidated ROE a little above that. The balance sheet is leveraged but typical for a regulated utility, and earnings are mostly insulated from the credit cycle. The stock has rerated from $62.77 to $70.68 since my last take with no change in fundamentals, so the gap to intrinsic value has widened.

I kept all drivers unchanged because nothing fundamental moved. The 9.8% trailing ROE is consistent with my 10.5% normalized figure (allowed ROE plus a modest parent-leverage uplift), and the capex-driven rate-base growth still supports about 7% near-term book growth, fading to 4%, below the risk-free rate. At a 7.3% cost of equity the excess spread is only about 3 points, so a price near 2.5x book needs higher allowed returns or faster growth than regulation delivers.

Value drivers

Return on equity (normalized)10.5%
Book-value growth (Y1)7.0%
Terminal book growth4.0%
Beta0.55
Failure probability0.5%
Cost of equity7.3%

Valuation bridge

PV of excess returns2.44B
PV of terminal excess6.39B
Equity value17.66B
÷ shares → per share$56.32

Projected excess returns on equity

YrBook equityROEExcess returnPV
18.92B 10.5%284.37M 264.99M
29.54B 10.5%302.28M 262.49M
310.18B 10.5%320.24M 259.14M
410.82B 10.4%338.13M 254.97M
511.46B 10.4%355.81M 250.02M
612.10B 10.4%373.15M 244.34M
712.73B 10.4%390.00M 237.97M
813.35B 10.4%406.23M 230.98M
913.96B 10.3%421.67M 223.43M
1014.54B 10.3%436.20M 215.38M

Key risks

  • Michigan regulatory or political pushback on rate increases as customer bills climb, which would compress allowed ROE or cause regulatory lag
  • Heavy equity issuance to fund the capex plan, diluting per-share book growth at elevated rates
  • Higher long-term rates raising the cost of equity and pressuring utility multiples, plus storm and reliability costs

Catalysts

  • Data-center and large-load contracts expanding rate base and the capex runway beyond the current plan
  • Favorable outcomes in upcoming Michigan electric and gas rate cases, or a falling rate environment

History

DatePriceIntrinsicMoSRating
2026-11-06$70.68 $56.32 -20.3% HOLD
2026-09-25$62.77 $54.41 -13.3% BUY
2026-08-14$70.51 $56.07 -20.5% HOLD
2026-07-02$75.92 $57.45 -24.3% HOLD
2026-06-23$75.33 $57.45 -23.7% HOLD