▟ Vinebot intrinsic value, daily

← back

ECHO EchoStar

telecom · valued with opus low conviction · deep-dived 2026-11-19

STRONG SELL
Intrinsic value$0.00
Price (at call)$96.92
Margin of safety -100.0%
vs market (rating basis) -99.8%

Spectrum cash and the SpaceX stake are the value; the operating business is shrinking and worth little.

The story

EchoStar is now a shrinking pay-TV and Boost wireless operator that is turning its spectrum into cash and SpaceX equity. It is shutting down its own 5G network and moving Boost to a hybrid MVNO on AT&T, so it no longer has a network moat. Pay-TV keeps losing customers each year. Most of the equity value sits in the spectrum sale proceeds and the SpaceX stake, not in operating cash flows.

Revenue growth moves from -8% to -10% because TTM revenue of 12.17B is down about 19% from 15.0B, as Boost subscribers fall and the network winds down. The 112.7% TTM operating margin comes from one-time spectrum gains and is excluded from the 8% target, which reflects an asset-light MVNO plus a run-off satellite TV business. All other drivers are unchanged: spectrum cash should cut the 30B of debt, but the standalone operating business is still fragile.

Value drivers

Revenue growth (Y1)-10.0%
Terminal growth0.0%
Forecast horizon6y
Target operating margin8.0%
Years to target margin5
Sales-to-capital1.00
Beta0.90
Failure probability15.0%
Cost of capital (WACC)6.5%
Terminal WACC6.8%

Valuation bridge

PV of explicit FCFF17.92B
PV of terminal value5.68B
Equity value0
÷ shares → per share$0.00

Projected free cash flow to the firm

YrRevenueGrowthMarginNOPATReinvestFCFFPV
1 10.95B -10.0% 91.8% 7.94B 0 7.94B 7.45B
2 10.07B -8.0% 70.8% 5.64B 0 5.64B 4.97B
3 9.47B -6.0% 49.9% 3.73B 0 3.73B 3.09B
4 9.09B -4.0% 28.9% 2.08B 0 2.08B 1.61B
5 8.91B -2.0% 8.0% 563.07M 0 563.07M 410.14M
6 8.91B 0.0% 8.0% 563.07M 0 563.07M 384.96M

Key risks

  • Boost subscriber losses accelerate on MVNO economics with no network differentiation
  • Pay-TV cord-cutting steepens, compressing satellite cash flow faster than costs
  • Spectrum proceeds are absorbed by debt, taxes and legal claims before reaching equity, and the SpaceX stake value is volatile

Catalysts

  • Closing of the AT&T and SpaceX spectrum sales and use of the proceeds to retire debt
  • A SpaceX liquidity event or mark-up that crystallizes the value of the stake

⚠ intrinsic value floored at 0 — the drivers imply the equity claim is worth less than the debt ahead of it · Extreme gap to market price — large, heavily-covered stocks are rarely mispriced this much; the gap likely embeds disruption, decline, or balance-sheet risk the model underweights. Treat as a flag to investigate, not a verdict.

History

DatePriceIntrinsicMoSRating
2026-11-19$96.92 $0.00 -100.0% STRONG SELL
2026-11-09$94.62 $0.00 -100.0% STRONG SELL
2026-10-28$90.39 $0.00 -100.0% STRONG SELL
2026-10-16$86.85 $0.00 -100.0% STRONG SELL
2026-10-06$98.21 $0.00 -100.0% STRONG SELL
2026-09-24$92.72 $0.00 -100.0% STRONG SELL
2026-09-11$91.85 $0.00 -100.0% STRONG SELL
2026-08-31$86.84 $0.00 -100.0% STRONG SELL
2026-08-17$91.89 $0.00 -100.0% STRONG SELL
2026-08-04$85.63 $0.00 -100.0% STRONG SELL
2026-07-23$92.28 $0.00 -100.0% STRONG SELL
2026-07-10$97.96 $0.00 -100.0% STRONG SELL
2026-06-30$100.84 $0.00 -100.0% STRONG SELL