▟ Vinebot intrinsic value, daily

← back

EXR Extra Space Storage

reit · valued with opus medium conviction · deep-dived 2026-10-15

STRONG BUY
Intrinsic value$107.03
Price (at call)$134.08
Margin of safety -20.2%
vs market (rating basis) +35.8%

Best-in-class storage platform priced for recovery; fair value hinges on housing thaw and lower rates.

The story

Extra Space is the largest US self-storage operator after the 2023 Life Storage merger, with about 4,000 owned and managed stores plus a large third-party management and bridge-lending platform. Demand is still weak: the frozen housing market has cut move-driven rentals, so same-store revenue has been roughly flat while new-supply deliveries slowly taper off. The balance sheet is investment grade (BBB+), with leverage of about 5x net debt/EBITDA, mostly fixed-rate, laddered debt. As a long-duration, low-capex asset, the stock trades closely with 10-year Treasury yields.

Year-1 growth of 3% assumes a modest recovery in same-store revenue, plus merger synergies and fee income, partly offset by refinancing at higher rates. Terminal growth of 3% sits well below the 5.19% risk-free rate and in line with inflation-level rent growth. Self-storage needs little maintenance capex, which supports an AFFO/FFO ratio of 0.87, near the top of the normal range, while beta near the industry anchor reflects defensive demand that is still rate-sensitive.

Value drivers

AFFO growth (Y1)3.0%
Terminal AFFO growth3.0%
AFFO / FFO ratio87.0%
Beta0.95
Failure probability2.0%
Cost of equity9.5%

Valuation bridge

PV of AFFO (explicit)10.52B
PV of terminal value12.55B
Equity value22.61B
÷ shares → per share$107.03

Projected AFFO

YrFFOAFFOGrowthPV
11.71B 1.49B3.0% 1.36B
21.77B 1.54B3.0% 1.28B
31.82B 1.58B3.0% 1.21B
41.87B 1.63B3.0% 1.14B
51.93B 1.68B3.0% 1.07B
61.99B 1.73B3.0% 1.01B
72.05B 1.78B3.0% 945.79M
82.11B 1.83B3.0% 889.93M
92.17B 1.89B3.0% 837.37M
102.24B 1.95B3.0% 787.91M

Key risks

  • Housing turnover stays depressed, keeping street rates and move-in volumes under pressure
  • Higher-for-longer rates raise refinancing costs and push cap rates and the terminal multiple lower
  • Sunbelt supply plus aggressive pricing from Public Storage and smaller operators limit pricing power on existing customers

Catalysts

  • Fed cuts and a mortgage-rate decline restart home sales and storage demand
  • New-supply deliveries reach a cyclical trough, allowing street rates to turn positive and same-store NOI to reaccelerate

History

DatePriceIntrinsicMoSRating
2026-10-15$134.08 $107.03 -20.2% STRONG BUY
2026-09-03$139.93 $131.00 -6.4% STRONG BUY
2026-07-13$143.96 $132.08 -8.3% STRONG BUY
2026-06-23$147.76 $134.34 -9.1% STRONG BUY