▟ Vinebot intrinsic value, daily

← back

GM General Motors

auto · valued with opus medium conviction · deep-dived 2026-11-20

HOLD
Intrinsic value$49.14
Price (at call)$81.75
Margin of safety -39.9%
vs market (rating basis) +1.1%

Still cheap on book, still sub-par on returns: the market is pricing a margin rebound that GM hasn't delivered.

The story

GM has a strong North American truck and SUV franchise and a captive lender, GM Financial, which makes it a leveraged, balance-sheet-heavy business. Operating margin has fallen from 8.0% to 2.1% as tariffs, EV write-downs and pricing pressure hit, and trailing ROE is now 6.5%, below the cost of equity. Book value is flat because aggressive buybacks absorb retained earnings. GM appears to be past the cyclical peak, and credit normalization at GM Financial is still a risk.

Nothing material has changed in the three days since the last take, so all drivers stay the same. A 9% normalized ROE sits between the depressed 6.5% trailing figure and the 12-15% peak years of 2022-23, and it remains below the roughly 11.4% cost of equity, so excess returns are negative. Buybacks keep book growth near zero in year one; the terminal rate of 3.5% stays below the risk-free rate, and the 8% failure probability reflects auto-cycle leverage and GM's 2009 bankruptcy.

Value drivers

Return on equity (normalized)9.0%
Book-value growth (Y1)0.0%
Terminal book growth3.5%
Beta1.40
Failure probability8.0%
Cost of equity11.4%

Valuation bridge

PV of excess returns-8.63B
PV of terminal excess-7.43B
Equity value41.46B
÷ shares → per share$49.14

Projected excess returns on equity

YrBook equityROEExcess returnPV
161.12B 9.0%-1.44B -1.29B
261.12B 9.0%-1.44B -1.16B
361.36B 9.0%-1.44B -1.05B
461.83B 9.0%-1.45B -945.96M
562.56B 9.0%-1.47B -859.43M
663.53B 9.0%-1.49B -783.82M
764.76B 9.0%-1.52B -717.60M
866.27B 9.0%-1.56B -659.48M
968.08B 9.0%-1.60B -608.37M
1070.20B 9.0%-1.65B -563.35M

Key risks

  • Tariff and trade costs persist, keeping margins near 2% instead of recovering
  • A credit-cycle downturn raises GM Financial's loan losses and lowers used-car residual values at the same time
  • More EV write-downs and restructuring charges reduce book equity

Catalysts

  • Tariff relief or pricing actions restore truck margins toward 6-8%
  • Further large buybacks below book-justified value, or capital-allocation discipline on EV spending

History

DatePriceIntrinsicMoSRating
2026-11-20$81.75 $49.14 -39.9% HOLD
2026-11-17$83.67 $48.78 -41.7% HOLD
2026-11-12$88.90 $49.43 -44.4% HOLD
2026-11-09$86.16 $49.87 -42.1% HOLD
2026-11-04$88.34 $48.71 -44.9% HOLD
2026-10-30$85.72 $48.51 -43.4% HOLD
2026-10-27$76.31 $48.53 -36.4% BUY
2026-10-22$76.11 $46.11 -39.4% BUY
2026-10-19$83.96 $46.36 -44.8% HOLD
2026-10-14$84.00 $45.75 -45.5% HOLD
2026-10-09$82.25 $45.68 -44.5% HOLD
2026-10-06$80.23 $45.28 -43.6% HOLD
2026-10-01$77.00 $43.33 -43.7% BUY
2026-09-28$82.63 $43.88 -46.9% BUY
2026-09-23$83.45 $41.25 -50.6% HOLD
2026-09-18$86.62 $41.33 -52.3% HOLD
2026-09-15$87.16 $21.20 -75.7% SELL
2026-09-10$83.76 $21.64 -74.2% SELL
2026-09-07$87.76 $43.80 -50.1% HOLD
2026-09-02$85.63 $43.74 -48.9% HOLD
2026-08-28$86.18 $22.11 -74.3% SELL
2026-08-25$86.98 $21.99 -74.7% SELL
2026-08-20$84.96 $22.18 -73.9% SELL
2026-08-17$86.77 $22.02 -74.6% SELL
2026-08-12$89.35 $73.13 -18.2% STRONG BUY
2026-08-07$86.94 $22.12 -74.6% SELL
2026-08-04$87.68 $50.30 -42.6% BUY
2026-07-30$89.40 $59.10 -33.9% BUY
2026-07-27$82.64 $62.51 -24.4% STRONG BUY
2026-07-22$79.52 $67.68 -14.9% STRONG BUY
2026-07-21$75.80 $22.80 -69.9% N/A
2026-07-16$77.64 $43.22 -44.3% HOLD
2026-07-13$77.85 $43.11 -44.6% HOLD
2026-07-08$76.03 $43.30 -43.0% HOLD
2026-07-03$76.00 $51.22 -32.6% BUY
2026-06-30$77.34 $78.05 +0.9% STRONG BUY
2026-06-25$78.95 $69.10 -12.5% STRONG BUY
2026-06-23$78.95 $60.83 -22.9% STRONG BUY