▟ Vinebot intrinsic value, daily

← back

GS Goldman Sachs

capital_markets · valued with opus medium conviction · deep-dived 2026-11-09

HOLD
Intrinsic value$521.24
Price (at call)$865.82
Margin of safety -39.8%
vs market (rating basis) -17.9%

Elite franchise at peak cycle; at 2.3x book the price assumes ~18% ROE persists indefinitely.

The story

Goldman is a top-tier global investment-banking, trading and prime-brokerage franchise with a growing share of fee-based asset and wealth management, now earning about 17.9% trailing ROE in a strong capital-markets cycle (record trading, a recovery in M&A and IPOs, and lighter capital rules). Its balance sheet is well capitalized and liquid but still levered and tied to markets. Its 2014-2024 ROE ran roughly 7-23% and averaged near 11-12%. With revenue at a record 64.5B, the current year looks like a cyclical peak, not a new normal. At about 2.3x book of 109.8B, the price implies ROE stays in the high teens indefinitely.

Normalized ROE rises slightly from 13.5% to 14% for three reasons: lower regulatory capital requirements (softer Basel endgame and stress capital buffer), the exit from consumer lending, and a larger share of stable fee revenue. I still mean-revert well below the 17.9% peak, because trading and advisory returns are cyclical. Heavy buybacks keep book growth near 6%, terminal book growth stays just under the 4.86% risk-free rate, and beta stays at 1.35 to reflect market-linked earnings and leverage.

Value drivers

Return on equity (normalized)14.0%
Book-value growth (Y1)6.0%
Terminal book growth4.6%
Beta1.35
Failure probability0.5%
Cost of equity10.9%

Valuation bridge

PV of excess returns20.69B
PV of terminal excess20.59B
Equity value150.34B
÷ shares → per share$521.24

Projected excess returns on equity

YrBook equityROEExcess returnPV
1109.82B 14.0%3.37B 3.04B
2116.41B 13.9%3.43B 2.79B
3123.21B 13.8%3.49B 2.55B
4130.22B 13.6%3.53B 2.33B
5137.43B 13.5%3.56B 2.12B
6144.82B 13.4%3.58B 1.92B
7152.38B 13.3%3.59B 1.74B
8160.10B 13.2%3.58B 1.56B
9167.96B 13.1%3.56B 1.40B
10175.95B 12.9%3.52B 1.25B

Key risks

  • Capital-markets downturn: trading and deal volumes reverse from record levels and ROE falls back toward 10%
  • Credit and counterparty losses from private credit, leveraged lending or prime-brokerage exposure in a market dislocation
  • Regulation reverses, raising capital requirements again, or a large litigation or conduct event

Catalysts

  • Final Basel endgame and stress-capital-buffer rules release excess capital for larger buybacks
  • Asset and wealth management growth lifts the share of durable fee revenue and supports a structurally higher multiple

History

DatePriceIntrinsicMoSRating
2026-11-09$865.82 $521.24 -39.8% HOLD
2026-10-14$891.91 $496.71 -44.3% HOLD
2026-09-18$951.47 $497.30 -47.7% HOLD
2026-08-25$1,036.28 $506.88 -51.1% HOLD
2026-07-30$980.75 $486.38 -50.4% HOLD
2026-07-03$1,021.00 $448.51 -56.1% SELL
2026-06-23$1,094.44 $412.39 -62.3% SELL