▟ Vinebot intrinsic value, daily

← back

MSCI MSCI

exchanges · valued with opus medium conviction · deep-dived 2026-11-19

HOLD
Intrinsic value$465.35
Price (at call)$636.90
Margin of safety -26.9%
vs market (rating basis) -1.4%

Elite moat, fully priced: 637 assumes compounding that 10% growth and mid-50s margins cannot deliver.

The story

MSCI runs a toll-road franchise in indexes, risk analytics and ESG data. Its indexes are embedded in benchmarks, ETF licensing and passive mandates, which makes switching costs very high and pricing power durable. It is a mature compounder: recurring subscriptions grow high single digits, and asset-based fees amplify market cycles. Reinvestment needs are light outside acquisitions.

Nothing material has changed since 2026-11-06. TTM revenue of 3.43B (about 9.6% growth) and a 55.4% margin match the prior drivers, so I am keeping them all. The reported sales-to-capital of 0.97 is distorted by acquisition goodwill, so 2.2 stays as the measure of incremental organic reinvestment. A 12-year horizon fits a moat this durable, while 58% margins assume only modest operating leverage above the current mid-50s.

Value drivers

Revenue growth (Y1)9.5%
Terminal growth4.0%
Forecast horizon12y
Target operating margin58.0%
Years to target margin5
Sales-to-capital2.20
Beta1.05
Failure probability1.0%
Cost of capital (WACC)8.6%
Terminal WACC8.4%

Valuation bridge

PV of explicit FCFF16.95B
PV of terminal value22.35B
Equity value33.27B
÷ shares → per share$465.35

Projected free cash flow to the firm

YrRevenueGrowthMarginNOPATReinvestFCFFPV
1 3.76B 9.5% 55.9% 1.69B 148.21M 1.54B 1.42B
2 4.10B 9.0% 56.4% 1.86B 153.75M 1.71B 1.45B
3 4.44B 8.5% 57.0% 2.04B 158.28M 1.88B 1.47B
4 4.80B 8.0% 57.5% 2.22B 161.63M 2.06B 1.48B
5 5.16B 7.5% 58.0% 2.41B 163.65M 2.24B 1.49B
6 5.52B 7.0% 58.0% 2.58B 164.20M 2.41B 1.47B
7 5.88B 6.5% 58.0% 2.74B 163.14M 2.58B 1.45B
8 6.23B 6.0% 58.0% 2.91B 160.38M 2.75B 1.42B
9 6.58B 5.5% 58.0% 3.07B 155.84M 2.91B 1.39B
10 6.91B 5.0% 58.0% 3.22B 149.46M 3.07B 1.35B
11 7.22B 4.5% 58.0% 3.37B 141.24M 3.23B 1.30B
12 7.50B 4.0% 58.0% 3.50B 131.20M 3.37B 1.26B

Key risks

  • Fee compression in passive and ETF licensing as asset managers push back on index costs
  • A market drawdown hitting asset-based fees, magnified by 5.7B of net debt
  • ESG and climate demand stalling, along with competition from S&P, FTSE Russell and in-house indexing

Catalysts

  • Private-assets and analytics cross-sell lifting subscription growth back toward double digits
  • Sustained buybacks and AUM-driven margin expansion beyond 58%

History

DatePriceIntrinsicMoSRating
2026-11-19$636.90 $465.35 -26.9% HOLD
2026-11-06$655.91 $404.85 -38.3% HOLD
2026-10-26$615.62 $394.33 -35.9% HOLD
2026-10-13$568.01 $363.65 -36.0% BUY
2026-09-30$539.76 $364.21 -32.5% BUY
2026-09-17$540.61 $322.51 -40.3% BUY
2026-09-04$574.65 $336.97 -41.4% BUY
2026-08-24$563.49 $339.34 -39.8% BUY
2026-08-11$563.08 $342.19 -39.2% BUY
2026-07-29$579.39 $305.41 -47.3% HOLD
2026-07-15$611.43 $283.85 -53.6% HOLD
2026-07-02$582.03 $293.62 -49.6% HOLD
2026-06-23$581.51 $297.33 -48.9% HOLD