▟ Vinebot intrinsic value, daily

← back

NI NiSource

utility · valued with opus medium conviction · deep-dived 2026-10-15

HOLD
Intrinsic value$34.51
Price (at call)$41.26
Margin of safety -16.4%
vs market (rating basis) +8.6%

Quality regulated compounder, but 2.1x book already prices years of rate-base growth near allowed returns.

The story

NiSource is now a pure-play regulated gas and electric utility (NIPSCO plus Columbia Gas in six states), earning near its allowed returns of roughly 9.5-10.5% on a fast-growing rate base. Its roughly $19B+ five-year capex plan, with a large NIPSCO generation build and data-center-driven GenCo load, is expected to compound rate base at about 8-10% a year. The balance sheet is levered but investment-grade, with equity needs partly met by the NIPSCO minority stake sale and ATM issuance. Utilities don't run on a credit cycle; the swing factors here are regulatory outcomes and interest rates.

ROE is set slightly above trailing 9.6% because recent Indiana and Columbia rate cases have moved earned returns toward allowed returns of about 10%, and data-center contracts carry protective terms. First-year book growth of 8% tracks rate-base capex net of dilution. Terminal growth of 4.5% sits below the 5.19% risk-free rate. A beta of 0.6 is slightly above the 0.55 anchor because of elevated capex and leverage. At about 2.1x book, the market is pricing in a long runway of rate-base growth above cost of equity, which explains much of the gap to the 28 USD baseline.

Value drivers

Return on equity (normalized)10.2%
Book-value growth (Y1)8.0%
Terminal book growth4.5%
Beta0.60
Failure probability1.0%
Cost of equity7.9%

Valuation bridge

PV of excess returns1.95B
PV of terminal excess5.32B
Equity value16.55B
÷ shares → per share$34.51

Projected excess returns on equity

YrBook equityROEExcess returnPV
19.45B 10.2%218.30M 202.33M
210.21B 10.2%235.76M 202.54M
310.98B 10.2%253.68M 201.99M
411.77B 10.2%271.94M 200.70M
512.57B 10.2%290.42M 198.66M
613.38B 10.2%308.99M 195.91M
714.18B 10.2%327.51M 192.47M
814.97B 10.2%345.83M 188.37M
915.75B 10.2%363.79M 183.66M
1016.50B 10.2%381.22M 178.39M

Key risks

  • Adverse rate case or ROE cuts in Indiana or Ohio/Pennsylvania eroding the spread over cost of equity
  • Equity dilution and financing costs from the large capex plan if rates stay high
  • Data-center load and GenCo contracts slipping, or regulatory pushback on customer affordability

Catalysts

  • Signed large-load data-center agreements under the NIPSCO GenCo structure
  • Constructive rate case outcomes and timely capex recovery that lift earned ROE

History

DatePriceIntrinsicMoSRating
2026-10-15$41.26 $34.51 -16.4% HOLD
2026-09-03$41.15 $30.82 -25.1% HOLD
2026-07-23$46.57 $37.58 -19.3% HOLD
2026-06-23$47.26 $38.61 -18.3% HOLD