▟ Vinebot intrinsic value, daily

← back

NRG NRG Energy

utility · valued with opus low conviction · deep-dived 2026-10-16

STRONG SELL
Intrinsic value$9.77
Price (at call)$102.86
Margin of safety -90.5%
vs market (rating basis) -77.3%

A cyclical merchant power and retail business on a tiny book; residual income can't capture its buyback-inflated ROE.

The story

NRG is not a regulated utility. It is a competitive generator and retailer (Reliant, Direct Energy, Vivint Smart Home) that has added LS Power's gas fleet to capture rising data-center power demand in ERCOT and PJM. Book equity is only about $1.03B because years of aggressive buybacks and acquisition accounting have hollowed it out, so the trailing 82% ROE mostly reflects a shrunken denominator, not a durable franchise return. Earnings are tied to merchant power prices and capacity auctions, which are currently near a cyclical peak, and leverage has risen after the acquisition.

I cut ROE from the 82% trailing figure to 40%. That assumes power spreads and capacity prices fall back from peak while the buyback-depleted book stays small, so measured ROE stays structurally high. Book growth is modest because most free cash flow goes to buybacks rather than retained equity. Beta is 1.05, well above the 0.55 regulated-utility anchor, because NRG carries merchant commodity and retail-margin risk.

Value drivers

Return on equity (normalized)25.0%
Book-value growth (Y1)8.0%
Terminal book growth3.0%
Beta1.05
Failure probability3.0%
Cost of equity9.8%

Valuation bridge

PV of excess returns782.33M
PV of terminal excess303.69M
Equity value2.05B
÷ shares → per share$9.77

Projected excess returns on equity

YrBook equityROEExcess returnPV
11.03B 25.0%156.57M 142.58M
21.11B 23.6%154.02M 127.72M
31.20B 22.3%149.28M 112.73M
41.28B 20.9%142.25M 97.82M
51.36B 19.6%132.85M 83.19M
61.44B 18.2%121.05M 69.03M
71.51B 16.9%106.88M 55.50M
81.58B 15.5%90.42M 42.76M
91.65B 14.2%71.81M 30.92M
101.71B 12.8%51.24M 20.09M

Key risks

  • Power prices and PJM/ERCOT capacity prices fall from current highs, compressing generation margins
  • High leverage after the LS Power deal combined with a thin equity cushion; a Winter Storm Uri-type event could wipe out book
  • Data-center load growth arrives slower than priced in, or regulators intervene in capacity markets
  • Residual income on a buyback-depleted book understates economic value, so model output is unreliable in either direction

Catalysts

  • Signed long-term data-center power contracts that lock in premium pricing
  • PJM capacity auction results and ERCOT summer scarcity pricing
  • Deleveraging toward the target ratio and continued buybacks

⚠ Extreme gap to market price — large, well-covered names are rarely mispriced this much; likely embeds risk the model underweights. A flag, not a verdict.

History

DatePriceIntrinsicMoSRating
2026-10-16$102.86 $9.77 -90.5% STRONG SELL
2026-09-04$111.84 $7.06 -93.7% STRONG SELL
2026-07-24$142.99 $7.54 -94.7% STRONG SELL
2026-06-23$137.66 $7.68 -94.4% STRONG SELL