▟ Vinebot intrinsic value, daily

← back

NTAP NetApp

technology · valued with opus medium conviction · deep-dived 2026-10-13

HOLD
Intrinsic value$120.88
Price (at call)$239.18
Margin of safety -49.5%
vs market (rating basis) -7.9%

Quality storage franchise priced as an AI compounder; history says mid-single-digit grower, overvalued.

The story

NetApp is a mature enterprise storage franchise that has shifted toward all-flash arrays, ONTAP software and first-party cloud storage services on AWS, Azure and GCP. The installed base is sticky and margins have expanded sharply with the flash and subscription mix. AI data-pipeline demand has re-accelerated growth to about 7% after years of a roughly 3% CAGR. It is a late-stage, cash-returning business with a cyclical hardware core. The price assumes a durable AI-driven growth reset, which looks more like a cyclical upswing.

Year-1 growth of 9% credits AI and flash demand above the 7% TTM pace, fading to 3% by terminal, which sits below the 5.24% risk-free rate. The target margin of 28% is a little above the 26.2% TTM, reflecting software and cloud mix; I stop short of software-like margins because hardware competition from Pure Storage, Dell and hyperscaler-native storage caps them. Sales-to-capital stays near the observed 1.93 and beta stays at the industry anchor. Even with generous drivers, value lands well below the price, so the market is pricing a much longer or steeper AI growth run than NetApp's history supports.

Value drivers

Revenue growth (Y1)9.0%
Terminal growth3.0%
Forecast horizon8y
Target operating margin28.0%
Years to target margin4
Sales-to-capital2.00
Beta1.15
Failure probability2.0%
Cost of capital (WACC)10.2%
Terminal WACC9.5%

Valuation bridge

PV of explicit FCFF9.64B
PV of terminal value15.01B
Equity value23.74B
÷ shares → per share$120.88

Projected free cash flow to the firm

YrRevenueGrowthMarginNOPATReinvestFCFFPV
1 8.06B 9.0% 26.7% 1.66B 332.60M 1.33B 1.21B
2 8.71B 8.1% 27.1% 1.83B 328.00M 1.50B 1.24B
3 9.35B 7.3% 27.6% 1.99B 317.37M 1.68B 1.25B
4 9.95B 6.4% 28.0% 2.16B 300.44M 1.86B 1.26B
5 10.50B 5.6% 28.0% 2.28B 277.12M 2.00B 1.23B
6 11.00B 4.7% 28.0% 2.38B 247.55M 2.14B 1.20B
7 11.42B 3.9% 28.0% 2.48B 212.09M 2.26B 1.15B
8 11.76B 3.0% 28.0% 2.55B 171.32M 2.38B 1.10B

Key risks

  • AI storage demand proves cyclical and growth reverts to the 2-3% historical trend
  • Hyperscaler-native and Pure Storage competition compresses flash pricing and margins
  • NAND cost inflation squeezes product gross margins

Catalysts

  • Sustained double-digit growth in all-flash and AI-related bookings
  • Keystone/cloud storage subscription growth lifting recurring revenue mix

History

DatePriceIntrinsicMoSRating
2026-10-13$239.18 $120.88 -49.5% HOLD
2026-09-01$185.29 $91.19 -50.8% HOLD
2026-07-22$165.76 $92.46 -44.2% HOLD
2026-07-21$161.16 $93.75 -41.8% N/A
2026-06-23$157.82 $96.42 -38.9% HOLD