▟ Vinebot intrinsic value, daily

← back

PGR Progressive Corporation

insurance · valued with opus medium conviction · deep-dived 2026-10-26

SELL
Intrinsic value$113.39
Price (at call)$228.07
Margin of safety -50.3%
vs market (rating basis) -36.6%

Best-in-class underwriter, but at 4.4x book the price assumes peak 35%+ ROE lasts forever.

The story

Progressive is the best auto underwriter in the US, with telematics-driven pricing and a scale advantage in direct distribution, and it is now earning record returns: trailing ROE is 38.6% on $30.3B of book, and revenue has reached $91B. The balance sheet is conservatively reserved and the investment portfolio is short-duration. However, auto insurance is hard-market cyclical. Rate adequacy is at a peak, and competitors (State Farm, Allstate, GEICO) are restoring margins, so pricing competition is coming back. The 2022 trough ROE of about 6% shows how quickly underwriting margins can compress.

A second straight year of mid-30s ROE supports a small step up from 0.23 to 0.24, since Progressive's through-cycle average (about 20% in the 2010s, 25-30% in good years, single digits in 2022) is genuinely superior. Pricing the current peak as permanent would still be unjustified. Book growth stays near 10% because large variable dividends pay out excess capital, and terminal growth is capped below the risk-free rate.

Value drivers

Return on equity (normalized)24.0%
Book-value growth (Y1)10.0%
Terminal book growth4.5%
Beta0.85
Failure probability1.0%
Cost of equity8.8%

Valuation bridge

PV of excess returns23.90B
PV of terminal excess12.15B
Equity value65.71B
÷ shares → per share$113.39

Projected excess returns on equity

YrBook equityROEExcess returnPV
130.32B 24.0%4.61B 4.23B
233.36B 22.5%4.58B 3.87B
336.49B 21.1%4.47B 3.47B
439.69B 19.6%4.28B 3.06B
542.93B 18.1%4.00B 2.62B
646.17B 16.7%3.63B 2.19B
749.38B 15.2%3.16B 1.75B
852.51B 13.7%2.59B 1.32B
955.51B 12.3%1.92B 899.50M
1058.35B 10.8%1.17B 501.50M

Key risks

  • Soft-market turn: competitors cut rates and advertise heavily to win share back, compressing the combined ratio from about 86 toward 96
  • Loss-cost inflation from repair costs, tariffs on parts, medical severity and social inflation outpacing earned rate
  • Catastrophe and reserve-development surprises in the property book and commercial auto

Catalysts

  • Monthly combined-ratio and policies-in-force reports showing margin durability through the 2026-27 cycle
  • Size of the year-end variable dividend and any buyback signal on how management views excess capital

History

DatePriceIntrinsicMoSRating
2026-10-26$228.07 $113.39 -50.3% SELL
2026-09-23$206.94 $111.10 -46.3% SELL
2026-08-21$220.34 $99.58 -54.8% SELL
2026-07-20$207.95 $92.28 -55.6% SELL
2026-06-23$215.69 $97.69 -54.7% SELL