▟ Vinebot intrinsic value, daily

← back

PNW Pinnacle West Capital

utility · valued with opus medium conviction · deep-dived 2026-10-21

HOLD
Intrinsic value$91.33
Price (at call)$102.90
Margin of safety -11.2%
vs market (rating basis) +8.5%

Solid Arizona growth utility, but at $103 the price already exceeds a 9.5% ROE value.

The story

Pinnacle West (APS) is a vertically integrated Arizona utility. Phoenix's data-center and population-driven load growth is pushing a large rate-base capex program. Earned ROE (9.1% trailing) still trails the roughly 9.5-9.55% allowed return because of regulatory lag, but the push toward formula rates and new rate-case outcomes should narrow that gap. The balance sheet is investment grade but stretched by capex, which means steady equity issuance and dilution; the business is not exposed to the credit cycle.

Nothing material has changed since September. Trailing ROE of 9.1% is consistent with regulatory lag against an allowed return near 9.5%, so normalized ROE stays at 9.5%. Rate-base capex keeps near-term book growth around 5.5%, and terminal growth of 4.5% is held below the 5.12% risk-free rate. A beta of 0.55 matches the industry anchor and gives a cost of equity of about 7.6%, so ROE runs only modestly above it. The roughly 6% move to $102.90 is a price move, not a fundamental one; it now sits slightly above my previous $97 value.

Value drivers

Return on equity (normalized)9.5%
Book-value growth (Y1)5.5%
Terminal book growth4.5%
Beta0.55
Failure probability0.5%
Cost of equity7.6%

Valuation bridge

PV of excess returns1.13B
PV of terminal excess2.95B
Equity value11.07B
÷ shares → per share$91.33

Projected excess returns on equity

YrBook equityROEExcess returnPV
17.05B 9.5%134.45M 124.96M
27.43B 9.5%141.84M 122.53M
37.83B 9.5%149.42M 119.97M
48.24B 9.5%157.17M 117.29M
58.65B 9.5%165.08M 114.50M
69.07B 9.5%173.12M 111.60M
79.50B 9.5%181.29M 108.62M
89.94B 9.5%189.56M 105.56M
910.37B 9.5%197.91M 102.44M
1010.81B 9.5%206.32M 99.25M

Key risks

  • Arizona Corporation Commission rate-case or formula-rate outcomes that keep earned ROE below 9%
  • Equity dilution and rising financing costs needed to fund the capex program
  • Wildfire liability and extreme-heat reliability events in the Southwest

Catalysts

  • ACC approval of formula-rate mechanism reducing regulatory lag
  • Signed data-center load contracts lifting rate-base growth guidance

History

DatePriceIntrinsicMoSRating
2026-10-21$102.90 $91.33 -11.2% HOLD
2026-09-09$98.04 $97.32 -0.7% BUY
2026-07-29$105.33 $99.39 -5.6% BUY
2026-06-23$104.05 $103.87 -0.2% BUY