▟ Vinebot intrinsic value, daily

← back

SPG Simon Property Group

reit · valued with opus medium conviction · deep-dived 2026-11-02

STRONG BUY
Intrinsic value$172.63
Price (at call)$217.75
Margin of safety -20.7%
vs market (rating basis) +32.9%

Best-in-class malls earning real cash, but headline FFO is gain-inflated; fair value sits near the price.

The story

Simon owns the dominant US Class A mall and Premium Outlet portfolio, plus stakes in Taubman, Klépierre and retail brand ventures. Occupancy is near 96% and leasing spreads are positive because almost no new mall supply is being built, and tenants are consolidating into the top-tier centers. The balance sheet is A-rated with mostly fixed-rate, well-laddered debt, so higher rates hurt mainly through refinancing costs and cap-rate multiples rather than near-term cash flow. The latest year's 100% operating margin and $4.62B net income are inflated by non-cash gains (the TRG remeasurement and asset/venture sales), which pushes NI+D&A FFO of $6.48B well above the roughly $4.6-4.8B of recurring real-estate FFO.

Y1 growth of 4% reflects the NOI growth (3-4%) plus redevelopment yields that management has guided to, partly offset by refinancing at higher coupons. The 0.62 AFFO ratio sits below the usual 0.70-0.90 range on purpose: it first removes roughly $1.7B of one-time gains from the $6.48B FFO, then takes off about $0.9B of recurring capex and tenant allowances, leaving AFFO of about $4.0B. Beta of 1.15 is above the 0.9 REIT anchor because mall REITs carry consumer-cyclical and retailer-credit exposure.

Value drivers

AFFO growth (Y1)4.0%
Terminal AFFO growth2.5%
AFFO / FFO ratio62.0%
Beta1.15
Failure probability3.0%
Cost of equity10.1%

Valuation bridge

PV of AFFO (explicit)29.10B
PV of terminal value28.48B
Equity value55.86B
÷ shares → per share$172.63

Projected AFFO

YrFFOAFFOGrowthPV
16.74B 4.18B4.0% 3.80B
27.00B 4.34B3.8% 3.58B
37.26B 4.50B3.7% 3.37B
47.51B 4.66B3.5% 3.17B
57.76B 4.81B3.3% 2.97B
68.01B 4.96B3.2% 2.79B
78.25B 5.11B3.0% 2.61B
88.48B 5.26B2.8% 2.43B
98.71B 5.40B2.7% 2.27B
108.92B 5.53B2.5% 2.11B

Key risks

  • Retailer bankruptcies or a consumer slowdown hitting occupancy and percentage rents
  • Refinancing low-coupon debt at higher rates compresses FFO growth; terminal cap-rate expansion if long yields stay near 5%
  • Non-core ventures (brand JVs, Klépierre FX, mixed-use development) add earnings volatility and execution risk

Catalysts

  • Continued positive leasing spreads and redevelopment completions lifting NOI faster than guidance
  • Fed easing that compresses REIT cap rates and lowers refinancing costs

History

DatePriceIntrinsicMoSRating
2026-11-02$217.75 $172.63 -20.7% STRONG BUY
2026-09-21$205.32 $238.96 +16.4% STRONG BUY
2026-07-30$235.61 $292.66 +24.2% STRONG BUY
2026-06-23$216.74 $299.42 +38.1% STRONG BUY