TSLA Tesla, Inc.
Returns on book of about 4% vs a 12% hurdle; the $1.5T price is almost entirely an autonomy bet.
The story
Tesla is an EV and energy franchise with a fortress balance sheet (net cash, little debt), but its core auto returns have compressed sharply: operating margin fell from 17.1% to 5.9% and trailing ROE is about 3.9% on $82B of book. TTM revenue of $103.6B shows modest reacceleration, mainly from energy storage, but auto pricing pressure and EV competition keep margins near the cycle trough. The $1.5T market cap reflects autonomy, robotaxi and robotics optionality that book returns don't support.
I'm keeping the drivers unchanged because nothing material has changed since 2026-11-13. A 10% normalized ROE sits between the 3.9% trough and the 15-20%+ peak-era returns, credits energy growth and a margin recovery, and still falls below the roughly 12.3% cost of equity (5.1% + 1.6 x 4.5%), so excess returns are negative. Book grows with retained earnings and capex, and the terminal rate stays below the 5.1% risk-free rate.
Value drivers
| Return on equity (normalized) | 10.0% |
| Book-value growth (Y1) | 5.0% |
| Terminal book growth | 4.5% |
| Beta | 1.60 |
| Failure probability | 2.0% |
| Cost of equity | 12.3% |
Valuation bridge
| PV of excess returns | -12.61B |
| PV of terminal excess | -12.08B |
| Equity value | 56.29B |
| ÷ shares → per share | $14.24 |
Projected excess returns on equity
| Yr | Book equity | ROE | Excess return | PV |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 82.14B | 10.0% | -1.89B | -1.68B |
| 2 | 86.24B | 10.0% | -1.99B | -1.57B |
| 3 | 90.51B | 10.0% | -2.08B | -1.47B |
| 4 | 94.93B | 10.0% | -2.19B | -1.37B |
| 5 | 99.52B | 10.0% | -2.29B | -1.28B |
| 6 | 104.28B | 10.0% | -2.40B | -1.20B |
| 7 | 109.20B | 10.0% | -2.51B | -1.12B |
| 8 | 114.30B | 10.0% | -2.63B | -1.04B |
| 9 | 119.57B | 10.0% | -2.75B | -969.13M |
| 10 | 125.01B | 10.0% | -2.88B | -902.27M |
Key risks
- Auto margin erosion from Chinese EV price competition and an aging lineup
- Robotaxi/FSD commercialization delays or regulatory setbacks deflating the autonomy premium
- Key-person and governance risk, plus heavy AI capex that dilutes returns on equity
Catalysts
- Scaled, paid driverless robotaxi revenue in multiple cities
- Energy storage growth and lower-cost vehicle launches lifting ROE back toward the mid-teens
⚠ Extreme gap to market price — large, well-covered names are rarely mispriced this much; likely embeds risk the model underweights. A flag, not a verdict.