▟ Vinebot intrinsic value, daily

← back

WEC WEC Energy Group

utility · valued with opus medium conviction · deep-dived 2026-10-28

HOLD
Intrinsic value$85.83
Price (at call)$111.43
Margin of safety -23.0%
vs market (rating basis) -14.5%

Top-quality regulated compounder, but at 2.7x book the price assumes more data-center growth than allowed returns justify.

The story

WEC is a premium, almost entirely regulated Midwest utility: Wisconsin electric and gas utilities plus an Illinois gas utility, a 60% stake in American Transmission Co, and contracted renewables. Allowed ROEs are about 9.8% in Wisconsin and above 10% at ATC, and constructive regulation plus holding-company leverage have let it earn about 12% on parent book equity. Its data-center-driven capex plan (Microsoft in Mount Pleasant and others) of roughly $36B+ over five years is pushing rate base growth toward 9-10%. That growth is financed partly by new equity and hybrids, and the balance sheet is stretched but investment grade. The utility cycle doesn't swing much; the real risks are regulatory lag and the concentration of large-load customers.

I set normalized ROE at 11.5%, a little below the trailing 12.4%, because each jurisdiction's allowed return sits near 10% and parent leverage adds about 150bp on top. Year-1 book growth of 8% follows rate base growth after allowing for share issuance, and it fades to 4.5%, below the 4.99% risk-free rate. With beta 0.55 the cost of equity is about 7.5%, which leaves a positive but modest spread. The market price of 2.7x book only works if it assumes a long, high-growth runway from data-center rate base, which is why the baseline value (72.27) sits well below the price.

Value drivers

Return on equity (normalized)11.5%
Book-value growth (Y1)8.0%
Terminal book growth4.5%
Beta0.55
Failure probability0.5%
Cost of equity7.5%

Valuation bridge

PV of excess returns4.35B
PV of terminal excess10.15B
Equity value27.97B
÷ shares → per share$85.83

Projected excess returns on equity

YrBook equityROEExcess returnPV
113.61B 11.5%548.90M 510.76M
214.70B 11.4%575.95M 498.69M
315.81B 11.3%601.32M 484.47M
416.94B 11.2%624.61M 468.27M
518.06B 11.0%645.48M 450.28M
619.19B 10.9%663.55M 430.72M
720.29B 10.8%678.50M 409.82M
821.37B 10.7%690.04M 387.83M
922.41B 10.6%697.91M 365.00M
1023.40B 10.5%701.90M 341.57M

Key risks

  • Data-center load fails to materialize or gets delayed, leaving rate base built for demand that never shows up and putting pressure on cost recovery
  • Wisconsin PSC cuts allowed ROE or equity ratio in response to customer bill affordability concerns
  • Higher-for-longer rates raise financing costs and make the stock less attractive versus bonds, while equity issuance dilutes per-share book growth

Catalysts

  • Wisconsin rate case outcome and approval of data-center-specific tariffs (Very Large Customer rates)
  • Upward revisions to the capex plan or a confirmed second wave of hyperscaler contracts

History

DatePriceIntrinsicMoSRating
2026-10-28$111.43 $85.83 -23.0% HOLD
2026-09-16$103.51 $72.24 -30.2% HOLD
2026-08-05$109.25 $81.58 -25.3% HOLD
2026-06-23$114.14 $81.60 -28.5% HOLD