▟ Vinebot intrinsic value, daily

← back

WY Weyerhaeuser

reit · valued with opus low conviction · deep-dived 2026-11-09

SELL
Intrinsic value$9.12
Price (at call)$20.98
Margin of safety -56.5%
vs market (rating basis) -29.0%

Revenue has stabilized but margins haven't; 15.7x trough FFO still prices in a housing recovery that hasn't arrived.

The story

Weyerhaeuser owns about 10M+ acres of US timberlands and a large wood products business, so its cash flow follows lumber and OSB prices and housing starts more than lease escalators. Revenue has fallen from 10.18B to roughly 7.0B, and operating margin is down to 7.7%, a cyclical trough. Revenue ticking up from 6.91B to 7.00B is the first sign of stabilization. The balance sheet is investment grade, but the business is very rate-sensitive through mortgage rates and housing starts. FFO of 0.96B against 0.54B of capex leaves thin AFFO at a 15.7x FFO multiple.

Y1 growth moves from -2% to 0% because revenue has stopped falling, but margins have not recovered yet, so I'm not assuming a rebound. I keep AFFO/FFO at 0.62, below the REIT norm: raw (FFO - capex)/FFO is about 0.44, but part of the capex is reforestation and mill growth spending. Beta stays at 1.25, above the 0.9 anchor, because lumber and housing make this a commodity-cyclical stock, not a lease-based REIT. Terminal growth stays at 2%, below the 4.86% risk-free rate and in line with timber price inflation. The gap to the market is large and I accept it. The market prices WY on timberland NAV, land sales and natural-climate-solutions optionality, not on trough AFFO, and my model credits none of those.

Value drivers

AFFO growth (Y1)0.0%
Terminal AFFO growth2.0%
AFFO / FFO ratio62.0%
Beta1.25
Failure probability1.0%
Cost of equity10.5%

Valuation bridge

PV of AFFO (explicit)3.70B
PV of terminal value2.93B
Equity value6.57B
÷ shares → per share$9.12

Projected AFFO

YrFFOAFFOGrowthPV
1965.00M 598.30M0.0% 541.53M
2967.14M 599.63M0.2% 491.23M
3971.44M 602.29M0.4% 446.59M
4977.92M 606.31M0.7% 406.91M
5986.61M 611.70M0.9% 371.57M
6997.57M 618.50M1.1% 340.05M
71.01B 626.74M1.3% 311.88M
81.03B 636.49M1.6% 286.68M
91.04B 647.81M1.8% 264.09M
101.07B 660.76M2.0% 243.81M

Key risks

  • Mortgage rates stay above 6%, keeping housing starts and lumber/OSB prices depressed for longer
  • Canadian softwood lumber duty and tariff swings plus new supply compress wood products margins
  • Recurring capex stays near FFO levels, so AFFO and dividend coverage stay thin and buybacks or the variable dividend get cut

Catalysts

  • Fed cuts that lower mortgage rates and lift single-family starts and repair/remodel demand
  • Timberland or real estate sales at premiums to book value, plus growth in carbon/solar/mineral (natural climate solutions) revenue, which would confirm NAV

History

DatePriceIntrinsicMoSRating
2026-11-09$20.98 $9.12 -56.5% SELL
2026-09-28$20.01 $8.25 -58.8% HOLD
2026-08-06$25.84 $8.29 -67.9% SELL
2026-06-23$24.44 $10.72 -56.1% HOLD